7 Signs Your Website Needs a Redesign
When refreshing isn't enough
Every website eventually needs replacement. But knowing when is tricky. Invest too soon and you waste money. Wait too long and you lose business. Here are seven objective signals that redesign—not just updates—is the right move.
1. Mobile Experience Is Broken
The signal: Over 60% of web traffic is mobile. If your site requires pinching, zooming, or horizontal scrolling on phones, you're losing visitors immediately.
Quick test: Load your site on your phone. Can you complete the main goal (contact, purchase, sign up) without frustration?
Why updates won't fix it: Responsive design needs to be built in from the start. Retrofitting a desktop-first site rarely works well.
Data point: Bounce rates on non-mobile-optimized sites average 60%+ from mobile devices.
2. Speed Is Unacceptably Slow
The signal: Pages take more than 3 seconds to load. Users bounce. Google penalizes you in search.
Quick test: Run your homepage through Google PageSpeed Insights. Score below 50 is concerning. Below 30 is critical.
Why updates won't fix it: Slow sites usually have architectural problems—bloated code, poor hosting, excessive plugins. Band-aids don't solve fundamental issues.
Data point: Every 100ms delay costs 1% in conversions. A 4-second site loses 25%+ of visitors before the page finishes loading.
3. Conversion Rates Are Declining
The signal: Same traffic, fewer leads/sales. Your conversion rate has dropped year-over-year without explanation.
Quick test: Compare conversion rates this year vs. last year. Consistent decline of 20%+ signals structural problems.
Why updates won't fix it: Declining conversions often reflect changing user expectations. Your site that worked in 2020 feels dated in 2025.
Data point: Average website lifespan before major redesign is 2-3 years. After 4 years, performance typically degrades significantly.
4. Content Management Is Painful
The signal: Simple updates require developer involvement. Your marketing team can't make basic changes without help.
Quick test: Can your team update page content, add blog posts, and change images without technical support?
Why updates won't fix it: If the underlying CMS is wrong or badly configured, patches just add complexity.
Business impact: Content bottlenecks slow marketing. Every update that needs a developer costs $100-$500 in delays.
5. Security Concerns Are Mounting
The signal: Outdated platforms, expired certificates, or warnings from hosting providers. Maybe you've already been hacked once.
Quick test: Is your CMS and all plugins up to date? When was security last audited?
Why updates won't fix it: Sites built on deprecated platforms or with years of plugin accumulation often can't be secured—only replaced.
Risk: A security breach costs an average of $200,000 for small businesses, including recovery, lost business, and reputation damage.
6. Brand Has Evolved, Site Hasn't
The signal: Your visual identity, messaging, or positioning has changed, but your website still reflects the old brand.
Quick test: Does your website match your business cards, social profiles, and sales materials?
Why updates won't fix it: Brand misalignment confuses customers and damages trust. Piecemeal changes create inconsistency.
Consideration: If you've rebranded or significantly evolved your positioning, the website should lead that change, not follow it.
7. Competitors Have Passed You
The signal: When you look at competitor sites, yours feels dated, slower, or less capable.
Quick test: Visit your top 3 competitors' websites. Compare honestly: speed, design, mobile experience, conversion paths.
Why updates won't fix it: If competitors have raised the bar, meeting it requires matching their investment—not incremental patches.
Market reality: Users compare you to alternatives. Being "good enough" when competitors are "great" costs you business.
CHECKLIST
Website Redesign Decision Checklist
0 of 7 completed
MORE INSIGHTS
Related reading.
Ready to talk?
Book a call to discuss your project. 15 minutes, no prep required.